- Open Access
Deferring surgical treatment of ambiguous genitalia into adolescence in girls with 21-hydroxylase deficiency: a feasibility study
International Journal of Pediatric Endocrinology volume 2017, Article number: 3 (2017)
Genital surgery in Disorders of Sex Development (DSD) has been an area of debate over the past 20 years. Emerging scientific evidence in the late 1990s defied the then routine practice to surgically align genitalia to the sex of rearing, as early as possible. However, despite multitude of data showing detrimental effects to genital sensation and sexuality, few patients born with ambiguous genitalia have remained unoperated into adolescence.
We followed up girls with 21 hydroxylase deficiency (21- OHD) in genital morphology during childhood and acceptability among patients and parents of such an approach.
Preliminary results from 7 children, aged 1–8 years (median 4.5 years), suggest that it is acceptable among patients and families to defer genital operation in 21-OHD. All patients had a Prader stage III and above. Median clitoral length at birth was 24 mm (20-28 mm) and had diminished to a median of 9 mm (5-15 mm) at their last visit. Height and weight have remained strictly normal in all patients. So far girls and their parents have not expressed significant concerns regarding genital ambiguity.
With this encouraging data at hand, we propose to formally address levels of anxiety, adaptation and quality of life during childhood, with an ultimate goal to assess long term satisfaction and effects on sexuality through deferring genital surgery for adolescence.
Surgical management in Disorders of Sex Development (DSD) remains an area of controversy, even following the 2005 Chicago consensus, which attempted to delineate treatment guidelines and advocated a more cautious approach to genital surgery . For years, the norm in DSD, was to align genitalia with the assigned gender as early as possible. Supporters of early surgery have based their practice on a need to reinforce sex of rearing, while relieving parental tension regarding the ambiguity of the genitalia . Early surgery, when assessed in the immediate postoperative period was thought to provide ideal cosmetic and anatomical results, with the additional benefit that a procedure performed early enough in infancy would be forgotten by the patient.
It was not until the 1990s that this practice was challenged by patients themselves, who came forward with significant problems in adulthood, including anatomical difficulties in penetrative sexual intercourse and decreased genital sensation or ability to reach orgasm .
Multiple scientific voices have joined those of patients and support groups to question long term results of early genital surgery [5, 6, 12, 14]. Decreased genital sensitivity and need for further surgery in adulthood, as well as poor cosmetic results in the long run have been proven by studies in multiple institutions, suggesting dissatisfaction in a significant proportion of patients irrespective of geographical provenance [2, 6, 11, 14].
Despite concerns, inertia has perpetuated the practice of early genital surgery into the present, and, to date, there have been no series of patients left unoperated until adolescence or adulthood so as to form a basis for comparison. Current practice still favours early genital surgery, usually based on nebulous and unproven scientific facts, as shown by national statistics , audits of practice among pediatric surgeons , and the paucity of data on unoperated patients in series of 21-OHD patients. Nevertheless, the handful of DSD patients that have remained unoperated, seem to have similar genital sensation to normal controls, with numbers however remaining too small to draw firm conclusions on . With evidence on long term outcomes lacking, it is impossible to formulate a well-supported scientific argument for deferring genital operation.
During the last decade, our institution, a tertiary referral centre for complex paediatric endocrinological disorders, has had a policy of offering unbiased information regarding the pros and cons of genital operation to all parents of children born with 21- hydroxylase deficiency and Prader III-IV stages. Parents are given the opportunity to discuss the care of their child with a paediatric endocrinologist, a gynaecologist with expertise in paediatric and adolescent care and if requested, a paediatric urologist. The child and parents are followed at regular intervals irrespective of whether they have opted for surgery or not. During visits, we assess the child’s behaviour, her interaction with her parents, evaluate for the presence of parental anxiety and note down any evidence of disruption to everyday activities due to the ambiguous appearance of the genitalia, urinary symptoms or clitoral erections.
We are currently following seven 21-OHD girls with a median age of 4.5 years (range 1–8 years) whose operation has been deferred.
The first girl, named GK, was born 8 years ago. She was left unoperated following a decision from the parents and PB. After observing the girl during one year, it was clear that the length of the clitoris could be minimized with 50 mg hydrocortisone/m2 daily in four divided doses, bring serum testosterone and delta-4-androstenedione levels to under 0.02 ng/ml. Over the following years, GK’s parents did not express any concern regarding the psychological or physical well-being of their child, despite episodic clitoral erections.
Since GK’s experience was encouraging, this pilot 2-year observation was shared with CB and MC who used it to inform other parents. From 2010 to 2015, CB and MC have been following 6 more girls with 21-OHD, born with Prader III-IV stages, who were left unoperated. These girls are followed up closely, with regards to their growth pattern, the degree of change in clitoral size and their psycho-developmental adjustment. So far all girls and their parents have not expressed significant concerns regarding genital ambiguity, despite episodic clitoral erections. There have been no cases of urinary track infections. Median clitoral length in this group of patients at birth was 25 mm (range 20-28 mm), whereas at their last visit median length was 9 mm (range 5-15 mm p < 0.001, Wilcoxon signed rank test). Growth rate, height and weight have remained strictly normal in all patients (Fig. 1). The main characteristics of the seven girls are depicted in Table 1. Figures 2 and 3 shows the results of the treatment at age 1 month in girl ON followed by MC. Treatment in all girls was started at a dosage of 50 mg/m2 daily in four divided doses, a higher dosage than usually recommended, for the first year of life and 50 μg fludrocortisone administered twice daily, and 2gr NaCL daily divided in four doses.. Thereafter, the daily dosage of hydrocortisone was gradually reduced to an average of 40 mg/m2 for the second year of life and 10-25 mg/m2 from the third year of life onwards. The doses of hydrocortisone that we used are closer to the Japanese  than to the European or American guidelines .
The audit of our small series demonstrates that, at least in childhood, and with appropriate medical care and psychological support, it is possible to defer genital surgery. Whilst so far no major concerns have been reported from patients and their families, it remains unclear whether patients will continue to accept their diversity as they grow.
Clitoromegaly may be obvious enough to peers and may become the element and basis of bullying. One would have to put this in context of the current vogue among ‘normal’ women (with no genital ambiguity) to readily explore their genital area and opt for plastic surgery to their normal labia minora or clitoral prepuce, in order to diminish tissue that protrudes in the genital region . In this current trend, a girl growing with clitoromegaly and ambiguous genitalia should be under frequent psychological support to enable better understanding of the condition and reinforce strategies to cope with being diverse.
Nevertheless, the degree of clitoromegaly may not be accurately assessed at birth as the newborn’s genitals are under the full influence of adrenal androgens and maternal oestrogens. Although clitoromegaly is not reversible, anecdotal reports and our experience suggest that the clitoris could decrease in size as higher doses of glucocorticoid and mineralocorticoid replacement are instituted for the first year of life. Furthermore, as the child grows the relative larger size of the clitoris might become less evident.
A personalized regimen of glucocorticoids needs to be defined within the therapeutic window, maintaining complete suppression of androstenedione and testosterone production and avoiding the unwanted effects of chronic hypercorticism. Individualized dosage and daily administration timing should be defined pragmatically in each patient instead of a per kg dogmatic prescription expected to fit all cases.
Compliance to medication is a reported concern in 21-OHD, particularly when adolescents start to be more rebellious and independent, omitting dosages or resisting and resenting treatment all together. This explains why a proportion of patients operated in childhood may need revisions to the clitoris in adolescence because of regrowth of tissue in puberty, due to a resurgence of androgens. With this in mind a stricter control with more frequent visits and better psychological support would be required in adolescence .
When the girl reaches adolescence, an examination under anaesthesia, a cystoscopy and vaginoplasty will allow for an accurate evaluation of the girl’s genitalia, including measuring the width and length of the clitoris and assessing the distance of the urethral and vaginal confluence to the perineum and the caliber of the vagina. This examination is usually organized on a day surgery basis and can easily be accommodated around school commitments, so as to interfere to a minimum with the lifestyle of the girl.
A vaginoplasty performed in adolescence is technically similar to the one performed in infancy. Advantages in adolescence are the larger caliber of the proximal vagina, allowing for a better end result at the level of anastomosis. Certainly the presence of oestrogens should allow for easier tissue plane identification and postoperative healing. Further to these technical advantages, an adolescent is in a better position to perform postoperative vaginal dilation, which will be required to avoid the formation of strictures, a complication often reported in the literature in as high as 50% of patients having had a vaginoplasty in childhood [2, 5, 6, 11].
Irrespective of potential technical benefits of performing surgery later in life, a major ethical advantage stems from the fact that the patient herself can be involved in the decision to proceed or not with an operation to the clitoris, taking into account the implications of surgery, the benefits to appearance and the possible risks to genital sensation and sexual function. It is perceived that a number of patients may opt against surgery all together as they grow, either because of a decreased size of the clitoris (relative or true) or because of a concern of effects of surgery on genital sensitivity. In either case it can be her choice to proceed to a clitoral reduction, even if the parent or guardian still has the legal responsibility for the operation.
We will collect preliminary results over the next few years, regarding concerns stemming from the ambiguity of the genitalia during childhood. However, the final outcome of a study should be long term adjustment, both with regards to sexuality and quality of life. It is obvious that these results will be available fifteen to twenty years from now, when current infants with 21-OHD will be entering adolescence and adulthood. Development of a prospective study with long follow up needs planning not only with regards to a well-designed protocol and measures to decrease dropout rates and patients lost to follow up. We also need to provide continuity of care within our service, to the next generation of researchers and clinicians, the current trainees or young specialists that will be gathering and analyzing results in the future.
Preliminary results in 7 young girls now aged 1–8 years affected with 21-OHD and born with Prader III-IV stages suggest that deferring genital operation is acceptable among patients and families. A careful medical treatment allowed the decrease of median clitoral length from 24 mm at birth to 9 mm at their last visit. So far girls and their parents have not expressed significant concerns regarding genital ambiguity.
With these encouraging data at hand, we propose to formally address levels of anxiety, adaptation and quality of life during childhood, with an ultimate goal to assess long- term satisfaction and effects on sexuality through deferring genital surgery for adolescence. These observations may pave the way for a new management of the disease in a subset of patients.
- 17-OH- P:
21- hydroxylase deficiency
Congenital adrenal hyperplasia
Disorder of sex development
Arlt W, Willis DS, Wild SH, Krone N, Doherty EJ, Hahner S, Han TS, Carroll PV, Conway GS, Rees DA, Stimson RH, Walker BR, Connell JM, Ross RJ, (CaHASE), United Kingdom Congenital Adrenal Hyperplasia Adult Study Executive. Health status of adults with congenital adrenal hyperplasia: a cohort study of 203 patients. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2010;95:5110–21.
Creighton SM, Minto CL, Steel SJ. Objective cosmetic and anatomical outcomes at adolescence of feminising surgery for ambiguous genitalia done in childhood. Lancet. 2001;358:124–5.
Crouch NS, Deans R, Michala L, Liao LM, Creighton SM. Clinical characteristics of well women seeking labial reduction surgery: a prospective study. BJOG. 2011;118:1507–10.
Crouch NS, Liao LM, Woodhouse CRJ, Conway GS. Sexual function and genital sensitivity following feminizing genitoplasty for congenital adrenal hyperplasia. J Urol. 2008;179:634–8.
Fagerholm R, Sanntila P, Miettinen PJ, Mattila A, Rintala R, Taskinen S. Sexual function and attitudes toward surgery after feminizing genitoplasty. J Urol. 2011;185:1900–4.
Gastaud F, Bouvattier C, Duranteau L, Brauner R, Thibaud E, Kutten F, Bougneres P. Impaired sexual and reproductive outcomes in women with classical forms of congenital adrenal hyperplasia. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2007;92:1391–6.
HES. Hospital Episode Statistics. www.hscic.gov.uk/hes. [Online].
Hughes IA, Houk C, Ahmed SF, Lee PA, LWPES1/ESPE2 Consensus Group. Consensus statement on management of intersex disorders. Arch Dis Child. 2006;91:554–63.
Ishii T, Anzo M, Adachi M, Onigata K, Kusuda S, Nagasaki K, Harada S, Horikawa R, Minagawa M, Minamitani K, Mizuno H, Yamakami Y, Fukushi M, Tajima T. Guidelines for diagnosis and treatment of 21-hydroxylase deficiency. Clin Pediatr Endocrinol. 2015;24:77–105.
LWPES/ESPE, Joint CAH Working Group. Consensus stateent on 21-hydroxylase deficiency from the Lawson Wilkins Pediatric Endocrine Society and the European Society for Paediatric Endocrinology. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2002;87:4048–53.
Michala L, Liao LM, Wood D, Conway GS, Creighton SM. Practice changes in childhood surgery for ambiguous genitalia? J Pediatr Urol. 2014;10:934–9.
Minto CL, Liao LM, Woodhouse CR, Ransley PG, Creighton SM. The effect of clitoral surgery on sexual outcome in indivicuals who have intersex conditions with ambiguous genitalia: a cross sectional study. Lancet. 2003;361:1252–7.
Money J, Hampson JG, Hampson JL. Hermaphroditism: Recommendations concerning assignment of sex, change of sex and psychologic management. Bull Johns Hopkins Hosp. 1955;97:284–300.
Nordenstrom A, Frisen L, Falhammar H, Filipsson H, Holmadahl G, Janson PO, Thoren M, Hagenfeldt K, Nordenskjold A. Sexual function and surgical outcome in women with congenital adrenal hyperplasia due to CYP21A2 deficiency. Clinical perspective and patient's perception. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2010;95:3633–40.
Intersex Soeciety of North America. www.isna.org.
Yancovic F, Cherian A, Steven L, Mathur A, Cuckow P. Current practice in feminising surgery for congenital adrenal hyperplasia; a specialist survey. J Pediatr Urol. 2013;9:1100–7.
PB acknowledges AG and JG, the parents of GK, for making the initial decision that paved the way for this study.
The current study was part of the usual care of children with 21-OH-D, thus required no funding.
Availability of data and materials
The authors will make readily reproducible materials described in the manuscript, including databases and all relevant raw data, freely available to any scientist wishing to use them, without breaching participant confidentiality. They will make the databases described in the manuscript available for testing by reviewers in a way that preserves the reviewers’ anonymity.
PB made the initial decision of offering to defer surgical correction, had the first patient in this series left unoperated and drafted the manuscript. CB and MC followed the other 6 patients. LM drafted the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Consent for publication
Parents gave their consent for publication to the authors, who all consent for publication of patients’ data.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
All parents gave their oral consent for the decision of deferring surgery after being informed to the best of our knowledge about the known consequences of performing or deferring early surgery for their child. Given our previous observations in women who had early surgery, physicians in charge were in favor of deferring surgery in these patients.
About this article
Cite this article
Bougnères, P., Bouvattier, C., Cartigny, M. et al. Deferring surgical treatment of ambiguous genitalia into adolescence in girls with 21-hydroxylase deficiency: a feasibility study. Int J Pediatr Endocrinol 2017, 3 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1186/s13633-016-0040-8
- 21-hydroxylase deficiency
- Ambiguous genitalia
- Congenital adrenal hyperplasia
- Genital surgery