Skip to main content

Advertisement

Table 2 SMOG, PEMAT, DISCERN & Completeness ratings for Team Pages (TP) and Team Link (TL) webpages

From: Disorders of sex development (DSD) web-based information: quality survey of DSD team websites

Site Webpage Webpage Description SMOG PEMAT DISCERN COMPLETE-NESS
Understandability Actionability Hormone Surgery
Grade Levela % % max = 75 max = 75 %
A TP 1 Introduction: DSD clinic 16 62 20    48
TP 2 DSD Treatments 75 20   
TP 3 DSD Types 69 20   
TP 4 What to expect at first DSD Clinic appointment 62 20   
TL1 Health topic: CAH 18 62 20   
B TP 1 Introduction: DSD team 14 69 40    52
TP 2 DSD detection and diagnosis 67 0   
TP 3 DSD treatments 69 40 39 43
TL 1 DSD research study recruitment 14 69 40   
TL 2 Health topic: CAH 13 69 20 31 19
TL 3 Health topic: Hypospadias 14 69 40 32 31
TL 4 Introduction: DSD program 15 69 20   
TL 5 Overview: DSD and Gender program 17 81 33   
C TP 1 Overview: DSD Clinic 16 67 0    40
TP 2 DSD Types 69 0   
TP 3 DSD Treatments 67 0 23 28
TP 4 What to expect at first DSD Clinic appointment 67 0   
TP 5 DSD clinic contact information 62 40   
TL 1 Overview: DSD 13 69 0 19 18
TL 2 Health topic: AIS 13 69 0 32 25
TL 3 Health topic: CAH 12 69 40 34 31
TL 4 Health topic: Hypospadias 12 75 40   35
TL 5 Health topic: MGD 11 69 20 26 26
D TP 1 Overview: DSD program 17 69 40   18 Not codedb
TP 2 DSD types and treatment 70 0   
TP 3 DSD Clinic Contact Information 62 20   
TP 4 Health topic: DSD and Ambiguous genitalia 69 20 22 26
TP 5 Health topic: Cloacal malformations 62 20   
TP 6 Health topic: CAH 62 40   
TP 7 Health topic: Gonadal dysgenesis 62 20   
TP 8 Health topic: Vaginal agenesis 69 20   38
TL 1 Overview: DSD program 18 67 0   
TL 2 Overview: CAH care center 17 69 40   
TL 3 FAQ: CAH 14 69 0 42 32
E TP 1 DSD Resources 16 56 0    40
TP 2 Overview: DSD clinic 69 20   
TP 3 Health topic: Ambiguous genitalia and Gender determination 69 0   
TP 4 Overview: DSD and Gender program 69 20   
TL 1 Health topic: Micropenis 14 69 0 29  
TL 2 Health topic: Hypospadias 14 69 20   23
TL 3 Health topic: Ambiguous genitalia and DSD 14 69 0 19 23
F TP 1 Overview: DSD and DSD Clinic 15 69 0    56
TP 2 Overview: DSD and DSD Clinic, DSD Resources 69 40   
TP 3 DSD Types 67 0   
TL 1 Health topic: Turner Syndrome 10 62 0   
TL 2 DSD decision-making checklists 17 44 0   
TL 3 CAH decision making checklist 9 69 60   
TL 4 Hypospadias decision-making checklist 9 81 50   33
TL 5 MRKH decision-making checklist 9 69 60   39
TL 6 Overview: DSD 11 69 0 17 19
TL 7 Health topic: CAH (newborn) 12 75 33 40 34
TL 8 Health topic: CAH 11 75 33 36 36
G TP 1 Overview: DSD program 13 85 40    40
TP 2 DSD Clinic Contact Information 50 40   
TP 3 What to expect at first DSD Clinic appointment 60 20   
TP 4 DSD Resources 62 20   
TL 1 DSD detection and diagnosis 13 69 40   26
TL 2 Health topic: Hypospadias 10 81 33   40
TL 3 Health topic: MRKH 11 69 40   38
TL 4 Health topic: Turner Syndrome 14 69 60 33 27
TL 5 Health topic: Hypospadias repair 9 69 60   
TL 6 Reproductive organs images   69 20   
TL 7 Decision-making checklist 8 77 60   
H TP 1 Overview: DSD clinic 16 69 80    20
TL 1 Health topic: DSD 13 69 0 18 31
TL 2 Health topic: Hypospadias 14 69 0   25
I TP 1 Introduction: DSD and DSD team 15 67 20    36
TP 2 What to expect at first DSD Clinic appointment 69 40   
TP 3 DSD Types 70 40   
TP 4 DSD Resources 69 0   
TP 5 DSD Research Studies 69 20   
TL 1 Glossary: DSD terms 13 69 20   27
TL 2 Glossary: DSD tests 15 54 20 33 28
J TP 1 Overview: DSD and DSD Program 17 69 40    12
Mean 13.5 67.9 23.5 29.2 29.3 38.2
SD 2.6 6.2 19.7 8.0 7.0 14.3
Minimum 8 44 0 17 18 12
Maximum 18 85 80 42 43 56
  1. aGrades 13–16 indicate college level education needed to ensure complete comprehension and 17–18 reflect graduate training education necessary
  2. bSite not coded because webpages changed prior to completeness ratings